Cuba
Back   Follow the presidential candidates on Facebook Follow the presidential candidates on Twitter
 
 

All Issues
  Cuba
    Colonization, Independence and the USS Maine
    The Cuban Revolution
    Castro and Communism
    U.S. - Cuba post-revolution relations
    Central Issues
      Democratic Transition
      Cuban Thaw
    Candidates' Positions on Cuba
 




Colonization, Independence and the USS Maine
Christopher Columbus
Modern Cuba was 'discovered' by legendary Genovese explorer, Christopher Columbus, in the first of his four voyages to the New World, or as he stubbornly called it, the East Indies. Captaining the voyage onboard of his flagship, La Santa Maria de la Inmaculada Concepcion (The Saint Mary of the Immaculate Conception), the Genovese and his 90 men landed somewhere near Baracoa in the eastern tip of Cuba on October 27, 1492, and claimed the island in the name of the king and queen of Spain, King Ferdinand and Queen Isabella. A tumultuous 400 years of Spanish reign followed, but their sovereignty of Cuba and other territories in the region came to a crashing end by the close of the 19th century.

Cuban nationalists, who had been waging a war of independence against the Spaniards, repeatedly sought the assistance of the United States. The Americans though, were wary of involving themselves in the conflict, but reports of atrocities and massacres, coupled with a growing number of Cuban refugees to Florida and fears over American interests in the island, prompted President William McKinley to send in the USS Maine to Havana for reasons that remains unclear to this day.

The American administration, nevertheless, sought the permission of the Spanish government in Madrid before authorizing the Navy to send the second-class battleship from Key West on January 24, 1898. The Spaniards granted the request, but placed restrictions on the crew members from leaving the ship. 21 days later, the USS Maine mysteriously exploded while anchored in the Havana Harbor, killing approximately 260 American crewmen and locals. Subsequent investigation revealed that the explosion was caused by a mine planted near the ships' store of gunpowder, although no culprit was identified.

USS Maine in Cuba
The sinking of the USS Maine caused great outrage in the United States, and served as the primary catalyst for the resulting Spanish-American War (April 25 - August 12, 1898), which extended to Spanish territories in the Caribbean and Pacific. Spain, one of the most powerful nations in the world at the time, was shocked at the strength of the barely hundred year-old American Navy, and was, for all practical purposes, defeated within three months of the war. Hostilities were brought to an official end after both nations signed the Treaty of Paris on December 10, 1898, which saw Spain relinquishing its claim on Cuba, the Philippines, Puerto Rico, Guam and several islands in the West Indies, in return for a $20 million compensation from the United States.

The United States granted Cubans their independence on May 20, 1902. However, in return, America maintained a constitutionally-approved presence in the island, with rights to intervene on matters involving American security and finance. Additionally, the United States also entered into a 99-year lease of Guantanamo Bay through the 1901 Platt Amendment, which would later be extended for perpetuity under the 1934 Treaty of Relations.

The Cuban Revolution
Five decades later, and the Cuban dream was all but dead. The country, under the direct or otherwise, dictatorial rule of Fulgencio Batista, was a cauldron of corruption and oppression. Government policies were dictated by powerful sugar barons, the American mafia and underworld figures. The army and police were coopted into criminal activities and were used to stifle political and social dissent with brutal and horrifying swiftness. The socioeconomic imbalance left the majority of the populace struggling for survival, even as American companies continue to pour record breaking sums into the Cuban economy.

With hatred for the government simmering at boiling point, the stage was ripe for a revolution, and it came on July 26, 1953. The armed revolution was led by Fidel Alejandro Castro Ruz, the 27-year old Marxist-leaning illegitimate son of a Spanish-Cuban sugar baron. Fidel Castro, as he is more widely known, reacted to the military coup organized by former president, Fulgencio Batista, which ousted outgoing President Carlos Prio Socarras, after it became clear that Batista would lose in the upcoming presidential election. The young Castro was further stunned when the United States recognized the Batista administration.

Castro, whose faith in Marxism was sown during his two years of law study in the University of Havana, had received training in guerrilla warfare during his time in the Dominican Republic, helping the rebels there in their futile efforts to overthrow dictator Rafael Trujillo.
With the assistance of similarly Marxist-leaning military commanders and the rural peasants, the revolutionaries strangely attacked two heavily armed army installations, the Moncada Barracks and the Bayamo military post. They were easily defeated and Castro, along with the other leaders of the revolution, were captured and put to trial.

The revolutionaries attracted worldwide attention, forcing the Batista regime to conduct public trials instead of the expected closed-door executions. In his trial, Castro gave a highly charged four-hour speech that ended with the memorable words; "Condemn me, it does not matter. History will absolve me." The words struck a chord with ordinary Cubans, and he became their symbol of hope against the oppressive regime. Castro was subsequently sentenced to 15 years in jail. There were wide concerns for his safety, leading to heavy behind-the-scenes efforts for his release. It nonetheless still came as a surprise when two years later, Batista, under pressure from the international community, ordered the release of all political prisoners, including Castro and his lieutenants.

The revolutionaries regrouped in Mexico, and prepared for another assault on the Batista regime. They were wiser and more experienced this time around, and had the moral and financial support of sympathizers, freedom fighters, Marxists, socialists and revolutionaries from the world over. But perhaps most importantly, they had the support of the legendary and semi-mythical Argentinian, Che Guevara. Many have speculated that Guevara was the actual mastermind of Castro's second revolution, and helped shaped the young revolutionary into the man that he will eventually become - along with his hatred of imperialist America.

Castro, alongside his three most important lieutenants - his brother Raul, the anarchist Camilo Cienfuegos and his now good friend, Che - were among the 82 highly trained and highly armed men who sailed from Veracruz on the tiny yacht, Granma, on December 2, 1956. Under the cover of the night, they planned to sneak into Cuba. However, they were greeted by a hail of bullets courtesy of the waiting Army and Air Force. It was a slaughter, and only 12 of them survived. They lost everything - their weapons, ammunitions, money and communication equipment. However, Castro and his men quickly regrouped, and hid in the Sierra Maestra mountain ranges in southeast Cuba.

They had to adapt, and with the help of Che, with his extensive guerrilla experience in South America, began to make inroads with the rural folks. Castro, meanwhile, reconnected with his old network, and they made gains among young urbanites and students. One and a half years of guerrilla warfare inflicted the Cuban military with heavy casualties and strengthened the rebel's reputation, prompting Batista to mobilize a counter offensive against the rebels on May 24, 1958.

Despite marshaling seventeen mix-forced battalions for the offensive, code named Operation Verano (Summer), it proved to be an unmitigated disaster, as the revolutionaries, familiar with the terrain, armed with far superior tactics, and with intelligence gathered from supportive peasants, repeatedly defeated the Army's much larger forces. One battle in particular, the Battle of La Plata (so named because it occurred near the village of La Plata located south of the Sierra Maestra), saw the rebels defeating an approximately 600-strong battalion (100 dead, 500 captured) with only THREE casualties. It demoralized the soldiers, and prompted a significant number of desertions, swelling the rebel forces many fold. This was in spite of late support from the United States, who provided Batista with logistical, mechanized and munitions support.

Spurred by the unexpected success, and the growing support of Cubans in general, Castro left the mountains and ordered his forces to engage the army directly. A five-month battle ensued, culminating with the Battle of Santa Clara on December 31, 1958. In what is probably the first large scale head-to-head military engagement of the three-year revolution, a combined force led by Che Guevara defeated the 31st Regiment of the Rural Guard and the Leoncio Vidal Regiment led by Colonel Casillas Lumpuy, in open battle, a result that sent shock waves throughout the island and the United States. President Batista immediately threw in the towel and fled the country, and he was soon followed by Americans, who left the island by the thousands.

Castro declared victory on January 1, 1959, and triumphantly marched towards Havana.

Castro and Communism
The victorious revolutionaries immediately set upon forming an interim government, and one of its first tasks was to uncover Batista-loyalists hidden within the ranks of the army and civil service.
Hundreds were captured and rushed through a swift military trial before being summarily executed. The international and American press roared with disapproval, but the news was greeted with approval by a majority of the populace, still caught up in the euphoria of the revolution and lingering hatred of the Batista regime. Executions were held in sporting arenas, with thousands of Cubans watching, with a few even broadcasted on television.

Castro announced the appointment of former judge Manuel Urrutia as president and Professor Jose Miro Cardona as Prime Minister, while an election would be held within eighteen months. However, Castro fell out with both men shortly thereafter, and he became the country's Prime Minister as Cardona went into exile on February 16, 1959.

cheandgang
Castro solidified his status as the hero for the oppressed with the establishment of the Ministerio de Recuperacion de Bienes Malversados (Ministry for the Recovery of Misappropriated Assets). Armed with the newly passed 1959 Agrarian Reform Law, the government nationalized private land, businesses and properties, including those belonging to foreigners. The confiscated lands were redistributed to farmers. Private American interests totaling almost a billion dollar were confiscated, and reimbursed with nominal sums. More damagingly, Castro ordered the nationalization of American banks in Cuba, including Chase Manhattan Bank and the First National Bank of Boston.

The actions of the new government outraged the Eisenhower administration, which responded by severing diplomatic ties with the Cubans and freezing all their assets in American banks. Eisenhower also ordered an immediate halt to sugar and cigar imports from the island. Castro, who had kept his political persuasion under wraps prior to this in the hope of gaining the recognition of the Americans, immediately set his sights on wooing the Soviet Union. The Soviets responded warmly to the Cuban approach, and provided extensive support (manpower, technical expertise and equipment) towards their rebuilding efforts. They also found a new market for Cuban sugar exports, in the form of their satellite states in Eastern Europe. A credit line for oil purchases was also extended to the Cubans. On April 19, 1961, Castro announced that the Cuban revolution was socialistic in nature. Twelve days later, Castro officially announced that Cuba was a socialist nation.

American President Dwight D. Eisenhower, fearing a new Soviet satellite state so close to the border, gave the green light to a CIA assassination proposal - using mafia hit men. The CIA's Head of the Directorate for Plans, Richard Bissels, his deputy Richard Helms, and Sidney Gottlieb, Head of the Technical Services Staff (the trio behind the infamous Executive Plan), organized several unsuccessful assassination attempts on Castro with the help of the mafia (involving some of the biggest mob figures of the day, including Johnny Roselli, Sam Giancana, Carlos Marcello, Santos Trafficante and Meyer Lansky). The CIA, concurrent to these attempts, also initiated Operation Mongoose, a plan to train Cuban exiles to invade, destabilize and overthrow the Castro regime through direct engagement, sabotage and psychological warfare.
(Note: Castro would later claim that there were over twenty failed CIA-organized assassination attempts on his life)

Amidst all of this, Castro continued with his brutal crackdown on suspected dissidents, and the promised election was shelved indefinitely under the pretext of national unity. Over a quarter of a million Cubans fled the country, with a majority of them sneaking into the United States illegally. A common refrain heard among them at the time was Cuba has traded one dictator for another. Additionally, Castro, ironically, views homosexuality, gambling and alcohol as detrimental vices, and came down hard on people involved in these activities.

CIA's director, Allen W. Dulles, briefed the new Kennedy administration on Operation Mongoose, and after some tinkering, it was approved by President John F. Kennedy, based on the recommendation of his brother Bobby, despite protests from his senior advisors. The Bay of Pigs Invasion, using CIA-trained Cuban exiles backed by limited American air cover, proved to be a major disaster.

On April 14, 1961, eight American B-26 bombers obliterated the Cuban air force. A planned rapid deployment of soldiers on the Bahia de Cochinos (Bay of Pigs) was delayed, and when they finally arrived two days later, the Cuban army was lying in wait. Two of the five commercial freights carrying 1,400 counterrevolutionaries were sunk a few miles from the coast, and the majority of the rest were captured or killed. The two-year operation went down in flames in the space of three days. It was a humiliating defeat for the Americans.

Castro, now fearful not only for his life but of an American invasion, approached Moscow for help. Marshal Sergey Biryuzov, the Soviet's Chief of the General Staff of the Armed Forces, secretly met with Castro in Havana on May 29, 1962, to discuss the deployment of Soviet nuclear warheads in Cuba. Ten weeks later, the first batch of the nuclear warheads arrived. Almost a month later, on October 14, 1962, a US Air Force U-2 high-altitude reconnaissance craft spotted the construction of seven missile sites in San Cristobal. A second flight three days later confirmed the existence of Soviet-made SS-5 intermediate-range ballistic missiles equipped with nuclear warheads. These missiles were fully capable of reaching Washington and most of mainland America within a couple of hours, a strategic checkmate for the Soviets.

Kennedy briefed Congressional leaders on the situation on October 22, and shortly thereafter, instructed the military to go to DEFCON 3. He also announced the news to a frightened nation through a televised speech the same day. Kennedy instructed a naval blockade of Cuba to prevent the rest of the equipment from being delivered and publicly demanded the removal of the missiles.

The United States presented their case to the United Nations, complete with photographic proofs, and received a near unanimous support from the Security Council and the general assembly. Castro reportedly wrote to Nikita Khrushchev, the Soviet Premier, urging them to stand their ground, assuring the support of Cuba even if war breaks out. But as the specter of a nuclear war became a very real possibility, the Soviets eventually backed down, and announced on October 29, 1962, the removal of their nuclear missiles and equipment from Cuba. In return, the United States pledged that Cuba will not be invaded. The incident drove a deep wedge in Cuban-American ties, and set the tone of their relationship for the next 53 years, under nine consecutive American presidents.

U.S. - Cuba post-revolution relations
Reaching deep into the paranoid auspices of the Kennedy administration, Fidel Castro’s fledging post-revolutionary state lay a mere ninety-three miles south of the United States mainland, politically prodding and poking at the ideological differences that persistently beset the two nations. The quasi-rhetorical ‘revolutionary propaganda war’ that both of these two politically distinct countries had partaken in had reached it’s peak by the early 1960’s, with sustained attempts by one another to persistently outflank and outmaneuver their opposing propagandistic tendencies. It might have been naive to suggest that an elongated Caribbean island roughly the size the of Virginia would have had the audacity in conjunction with the Soviet Union to possibly commence an event that may have resulted in nuclear apocalypse, yet this very well nearly happened during the Cold War .

Beyond the tense situation between the United States and Cuba that plagued much of the 1960’s, it is important to take into account the efforts through diplomatic means pursued by contemporary U.S administrations to isolate and neutralize Cuba as a regional threat. From what started as a war of revolutionary ideas, ended as a war of economic constraints, as the ‘el bloqueo’ formed a stranglehold that was to define U.S policies towards Cuba for the next half century.

If one was to assess what a modern nation-state needs to survive, three criterion come to mind; commerce, finance and economic stability, yet it was the U.S led trade embargo that came to define the crippling effects such resolutions had on Cuba. Essentially a Cold War relic, the island takes its centrally planned economy from the theorem of Marxist-Leninist ideas, utilizing the auspices of ‘self reliance’, yet it is international trade that a nation needs to survive in a globalized world.

The full trade embargo imposed by the United States has caused the Cuban economy to stagnate for many decades, and it is often the pressure from the Cuban-American community that has been trusted to express the prospect of reform into the limelight. A seismic shift has taken place from the opinions within the Cuban-American sphere of influence, as a new generation of homegrown domiciles express their grievances at justifying a historic policy of economic strangulation towards the birthplace of their parents.

As attitudes change with each passing generation, the incumbent Obama administration announced the resumption of diplomatic reconciliations in a historic move to normalize relations between the two nations. Barack Obama recognized that an ‘isolationist approach’ was no longer feasible, and steps had to be taken in order to bring Cuba out of the cold. "When the United States shuttered our embassy in 1961, I don't think anyone thought it would be more than half a century before it reopened," Obama remarked as he gave a press conference on the matter in July 2015.

Curiously, Cuba was on the list of ‘State Sponsors of Terrorism’, with its inauguration under such a label commencing in 1982. Although it’s implications did not necessarily involve terrorism in it’s most traditional form, Castro’s government at the time was seen to sympathize with corresponding left-wing and socialist movements throughout Latin America and Africa, notably providing military support towards Marxist forces in Angola during their post-independence quagmire. In April 2015, Cuba was finally deleted from the dreaded list, easing its transition into the international community as viable nation no longer susceptible of supporting dubious leftist guerrilla campaigns.

Contemporary Cuba is at a crossroads, seamlessly sitting on a precarious fence between a socialist revolutionary dogma, and an open hand from the United States. Minor attempts at market liberalization have emerged, much on par with what China went through following the death of Mao Zedong, and greater fiscal transparency is being carefully implemented across various sectors of the economy. Cuba is fast becoming past the point of no return as the tides have changed in favor of diplomatic mediacy over isolationist dogma.

Central Issues

Democratic Transition
At the forefront of any U.S diplomatic policy, the agenda of democratization is often gifted as the primary reason for the pursual of war or peace. Democracy as a concept has been ingrained within American foreign policy when encompassing a variety of internationalist campaigns. To spread democracy was the official stance when sending troops to Vietnam, as was the case in Afghanistan and Iraq, yet it is often on a country's own terms that a transition towards democracy would be feasible. Although it have may have seemed back in the 1960’s that just applying economic sanctions towards Cuba would strangle it’s footing and international clout, it has taken half a century to finally realize that the gentile encouraging of democratic credentials towards the Castro regime has garnered more progress than the ‘el bloqueo’ ever did.

Back in 2004, President George W Bush inaugurated the first rumblings of policy change when he stated, “We're not waiting for the day of Cuban freedom; we are working for the day of freedom in Cuba.” The appetite for this degree of democratic transition was resolute, although it may not have seemed politically popular at the time to express such an opinion on a soap-box. Much of the American anticipation of Cuban democracy relies not surprisingly on the death of Fidel Castro, for which it is said that he is in ailing health following his decision to step down in 2008. The awaiting of Fidel Castro’s demise prompted the government funded ‘Commission for Assistance to a Free Cuba’ to publish a 93 page dossier recommending that a lump sum of $80 million USD should be injected into the presumptive transitional government of Cuba when communism finally reaches the end of the road. Whilst it may seen that this prospect might be just around the corner, the alleged oversimplification of what might become of Cuba may be grossly misaligned with what may become a volatile transition toward democracy.

Cuban Thaw
It may have seemed unimaginable that the traditionally frosty relationship between the United States and Cuba would eventually thaw into a modern diplomatic process of normalization. The ‘deshielo cubano’ effect took hold amongst sweeping reforms that have enabled channels of communication to emerge like never before. As the greater power for the most obvious of reasons, it was the responsibility of the United States to initiate the talks for it had the largest stake in removing the crippling sanctions Cuba had endured since the early 1960’s. A groundbreaking program of sweeping engagements were announced in December 2014 including;

  • The reopening of the United States diplomatic mission in Havana
  • The Cuban embassy’s re-inauguration in Washington D.C
  • The lifting of some U.S travel restrictions
  • Allowing U.S based banks access to the Cuban financial system


Although some of the progress made within the Cuban Thaw may be seen with rose tinted spectacles, it is important to assess the underlying animosity that still plagues relations between the two countries. The contentious issue of the U.S naval base at Guantanamo Bay has been a long running controversy, with incumbent Cuban president Raul Castro insisting on the immediate return of the territory at the southeastern extremity of the island. Moreover, Castro has been critical regarding some of the more historical aspects of U.S foreign policy, such as the supporting of authoritarian and despotic regimes in Latin and Central America largely throughout the 20th century. The admixture of mutual mistrust and diplomatic outreaching has proved to be a pivotal point of U.S/Cuban relations. Although the frosty relation has succumbed to thawing, not all challenges can be met through the gentle lifting of economic sanctions, and further dialogue is needed in order to address some of the more historical pinpricks that belay this precarious relationship.

Candidates' Positions on Cuba


Hillary Clinton
 
Gary Johnson
 
Bernie Sanders
 
Donald Trump
 


 Presidential Candidates
 
Third Party Candidates
Republican Candidates
Democratic Candidates
Libertarian Candidates
Independent Candidates
Green Party Candidates
Constitution Party Candidates
   



 2016 Election Issues
   
   




 Popular Issue Comparisons
 
1. Clinton vs Trump Controversies
2. Trump vs Clinton on Education
3. Clinton vs Trump on Gun Control
4. Trump vs Clinton on Abortion
5. Trump vs Clinton on the Deficit and Debt
6. Rubio vs Fiorina on the Minimum Wage
7. Clinton vs Trump on Abortion
8. Clinton vs Trump on Immigration
9. Trump vs Clinton on the Federal Budget
10. Clinton vs Trump on Guantanamo
  Based on 6,093 unique queries over the past 24 hours
 
Brokered and Contested Republican Conventions


Quicken Loans Arena, Cleveland, OH
July 18-21 2016

Origin and History Delegate Distribution
Party Platform Delegate Count
Cleveland Venues Brokered/Contested
Party Merchandise Convention Protests
   
 
 2016 Political Conventions
 
Libertarian National Convention
Republican National Convention
Democratic National Convention
 
cameras

Spy Cameras

© 2016 Politicks.org
About Us
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Contact Us
Back   Top    Follow the presidential candidates on Facebook Follow the presidential candidates on Twitter